Classical Athens And Han China Dbq Essay Sample

Posted on by Vimi

After viewing the documents, it is clear that Classical Athens and Han China are very different politically. Athens focused on the rights of the individual whereas Han China preferred dominance that used an imperialist approach. However, the reason for this difference in political beliefs can be based on the difference of population. It is easier to be a democracy with a smaller population than a larger one. That said it is also easier to rule many people with a select elite. Another difference is that their social aspects are opposites.

Athenians believed that everyone should obey the laws of society and turn in those who break them. Han china thought that it is better to obey the rules but should always prefer family over government. Despite many differences, both Classical Athens and Han China thought there should be class distinctions between poor and the wealthy, few and many, free people and slaves. In document 4, Pericles describes the Athenian form of democracy and a few of their laws. Pericles showed the importance for all men who are able to participate in government and politics.

Document 6 shows a conversation between two Chinese philosophers named Wan Chang and Mencius about how an emperor of Han China was “appointed” to office. Mencius indicated that the emperor himself was not appointed by peasants, but by “Heaven”. Documents 2 and 3 show the population differences and document 1 compared the size of Attica and Han China. Because Athens had a smaller population and a smaller province, a “true” democracy was easier to uphold. Fewer votes meant less of a challenge to keep count.

Because Han China had a larger population and a greater size a land, no one could truly voice their own personal opinion. Instead the emperor appointed smaller classes of rulers to govern specific areas. In document 9, a Greek philosopher names Socrates explains to one of his friends that citizens must obey and enforce the laws created by their government; if one does not obey those laws, then one cannot call himself a true citizen. Document 10 reveals the thoughts of one Chinese philosopher named Confucius about a citizen’s part in government.

Confucius believed that as long as an individual is a friendly and supportive then he is taking part of government. Confucius also believed that people should support their family, whether they broke the law or not. Documents 2 and 3 show two excerpts from philosophers in both Classical Athens and Han China that agreed on class distinctions. In document 2, the Athenian philosopher Aristotle believed that those born into a higher status should not learn the trades of the lower classes.

Aristotle believed that in learning those crafts, there would have been no difference between slave and master. In document 3, the Chinese philosopher Mencius told about the two distinctions of brains and brawn. Mencius believed that brains should rule and the brawn should work for the brains. Mencius believed that those who rule should be supported in full by those ruled. Both Han China and Classical Athens had a good political system. The major difference in government is that Athens was ruled by the citizens whereas China was ruled by the emperor and the appointed elites.

Han china believed family should support and protect each other, whether from the law or other problems. Athens believed the law should be upheld less chaos arises. Despite these differences, both China and Athens believed there should be class distinctions between slaves and elite due to the differences in labor. If a document derived from the slaves or the common people’s opinion, then an accurate view of government from the majority population can be made.

Do you like this text sample?
We can make your essay even better one!

order now

The Classical Athens And Han China Differences

The classical Athens and Han china differences

Han china and classical Athens shared many differences around the 5th century such as cultural image, cultural environment, social structures, and the overall similarities and differences.

Document B (population estimates from mixed sources…) states that the population of classical Athens in 422 B.C.E was to be 315,000 total. Whereas Doc C (population estimates from mixed sources) the population of Han china in 200 C.E was 65,000,000 total. Han china and classical Athens population was distributed differently. Like classical Athens population distribution was more general so it was divided in four sections which were free male citizen, free male non- citizens, free females and slaves. However Han china population distribution was more specific so it was divided into six sections which were emperor and appointed officials, educated mandarin bureaucrats, landed aristocracy, peasant farmers and some skilled urban works, merchants, and "mean people". Although Han china and classical Athens have many differences they also had some similarities like both had an underclass mean people in china and slaves in Athens. Another similarity was that they had was that a largely farm based population.

Document K (discus thrower) and document L (Ch'iu Ying, Landscape in the style of Li T'ang...) were also very different from each other. Document K (5th century) was more cultural base, discus throwers were among many competitors in the Greek Olympic Games. The Olympic Games were held every four...

Loading: Checking Spelling


Read more

Differences of the Elementary Education Between China and America

5270 words - 21 pages I. IntroductionA.Different emphases of Chinese and American elementary educationSchool, as the second class in a child's growth, plays an important role in one's life. However, according to the differences lying in the different situation, different countries have different education systems. Chinese and American education systems...

This paper highlights the differences between the Han and Manchu social groups, as well as the various social clashes and changes which existed in 11th century Chinese culture.

663 words - 3 pages The Qing conquest of Ming China placed the numerically superior ethnic group of the Han Chinese under the rule of the outsider Manchurians. The Han Chinese had governed China by way of the Ming dynasty for nearly three hundred years, until the Manchu Qing Dynasty usurped the Ming through...

Similarities and Differences of China and India

1505 words - 6 pages Period 4/5September 8, 2014Prompt: Analyze the differences and similarities in classical China and India.Classical India and China were among one of the oldest and most fascinating civilizations that have existed during the Classical period in 1000 B.C.E-600 B.C.E. As both civilizations...

Differences Between China and Saudi Arabia

572 words - 2 pages Saudi Arabia and China are quite different countries. The latter is much larger than the former. The former is the largest country of the Arabian Peninsula and it is located in Middle East, bordering the Arabian Gulf and the Red Sea, north of Yemen. The latter is the largest country in Eastern Asia, bordering the East China Sea, between North Korea and Vietnam. Although there some similarities between Saudi Arabia and China, there are also...

Raphael’s The School of Athens: Classical Philosophers in a Renaissance Work

1232 words - 5 pages The European Renaissance was the time period after the Dark Ages. In the Renaissance, radical new ideas like humanism and individualism took foot. Also, art and science were re-embraced for the first time in Europe since classical times. Art in the Renaissance became much more realistic and advanced using new techniques such as chiaroscuro (using high contrast to add depth to a painting), foreshortening (adjusting line length and angle to make...

Comparing and Contrasting the Han and Roman Civilizations

949 words - 4 pages Around the years 200 B.C.E two great civilizations emerged as powerful and influential Empires. The Han civilization and the Roman Civilization. Both civilizations contributed to the ancient world, with revolutionary technologies, literature, mathematics, and extensive trade. Although these were powerful nations, the causes of their decline were quite similar. Inept rulers, social discordance, and hostile incursions, are some of the numerous...

The Han and Roman Empires: A Test in Longevity

2037 words - 8 pages The history of the empires of Afro-Eurasia ebb and flow like an ocean tide; it's waves representing the degrees of dissension; its over bearing water levels claiming the dry shore in its path, claiming the sands as its people. Such is never permanent, soon the tides will recede and the sand will be claimed by yet, another tide; to repeat this process yet again. Two empires in Afro-Eurasia, born in the final years before the common era; defied...

Comparison of Athens and Sparta. Focuses on differences between the two city states i.e. Spartan militarism vs. Athenian arts, literature, culture.

1545 words - 6 pages Ancient Greece was a land of contradictions and conflict. Located amist ruggedmountains, the Greek mainland was both protected from its enemies, and isolated from its allies,making communication between the many Greek city-states extremely difficult. Each city-stateand the lands...

To what extent did internal factors bring about the fall of the Han Dynasty in China (200 BCE – 220 CE)?

2098 words - 8 pages The demise of the Qin Dynasty sparked the fear that another centralized authority could be harmful for modern day China. However, with such vast territory, China could not be ruled by local lords, simply because it would be counter producing for the conjunct advances, such as trading networks, technological advances, and agricultural advancements (Encarta). Centralized rule returned quickly to China under the hands of a commander named

The Classical and Keynesian Theories

840 words - 3 pages Economics studies the monetary policy of a government and other information using mathematical or statistical calculations (Differences). Classical and Keynesian are two completely different economic theories. Each theory takes its own approach on monetary policy, consumer behavior, and government spending. There are a few distinctions that separate these two theories. To begin, the Classical Economic Theory was made in the 1700's, which was...

Cross-Cultural Differences Between Doing Business In France And China

1970 words - 8 pages As we revel in the wake of Globalization, models of organizations and styles of management are becoming increasingly similar. However, this conversion has a limit. Some cross-cultural differences will not disappear so easily and managers will have to understand and appreciate these cultural ‘oddities' if they wish to run a successful business. Let us take China and France as examples of two very different countries that may have cross-cultural...

Categories: 1

0 Replies to “Classical Athens And Han China Dbq Essay Sample”

Leave a comment

L'indirizzo email non verrà pubblicato. I campi obbligatori sono contrassegnati *